The fallacy of blind authority

The Need to Trust Experts

In such a complex world, it is impossible to be an expert on everything.

We necessarily have to trust the authority of others: doctors, scientists, historians, etc.

Trusting authority is not, in itself, a fallacy. It is a practical necessity.

When Trust Goes Blind

The fallacy of blind authority occurs when we accept a statement as true simply because it comes from an authority figure, without subjecting it to our own critical scrutiny.

It is the relinquishing of our own judgment in favor of someone else's.

The Dangers of Blind Trust: This fallacy is dangerous for several reasons.

First, authorities can be wrong.

Second, knowledge is constantly evolving; What was considered truth ten years ago may be obsolete today.

Third, authorities may also have their own biases, hidden interests, or conflicts of interest that influence their claims.

Blindly accepting authority leaves us vulnerable to misinformation and intellectual stagnation.

Respectful Skepticism as the Antidote

The antidote to this fallacy is not a wholesale rejection of authority, which would lead to paralysis, but respectful skepticism.

This means