You are viewing free content. Unlock the full course to get your certificate, exams, and downloadable material.
Scoring Methods: Simple vs. Weighted Scoring Systems
Scoring performances objectively is key to fair assessments; engage with our insightful course focused on candidate evaluation methods that will equip you with the right tools.
Introduction: The Final Step in Candidate Rating
Once the interview has concluded and the rating guide is complete with all the objective notes, the next step is to assign a numerical score to the candidate’s performance.
This process is essential for fairly comparing different candidates who have been rated using the same criteria.
There are two main methods for calculating this final score: the simple method and the weighted method.
The Scoring Key
Both methods rely on a predefined [Scoring Key].
This key is a numerical scale (for example, from 1 to 5) where each number has a clear meaning. For example:
1: Superficial mention of experience; unconvincing.
2: Relevant experience, but little depth after follow-up questions.
3: Sufficient experience to be hired; meets the minimum standard.
4: Strong experience; convincing answer that meets all requirements.
5: Exceptional experience; an answer so strong that it exceeds the interviewer’s expectations.
It is essential to apply this key consistently to all candidates competing for the same position.
Method 1: Simple Scoring (Direct Average)
Simple scoring is the most direct and easiest method to calculate.
It involves assigning a score (e.g., from 1 to 5) to each rated competency, based on the evidence gathered in the guide.
To get the final score, simply add the scores for all competencies and divide by the total number of rated competencies. Example:
Competency 1 (Leadership): 3 points
Competency 2 (Communication): 4 points
Competency 3 (Experience): 5 points
Calculation: (3 + 4 + 5) = 12 / 3 competencies = Final score: 4.0 out of 5.
Method 2: Weighted Scoring (By Relative Importance)
Weighted scoring is a more advanced method used when not all competencies are equally important for the position.
For example, for a Software Developer position, technical competency ([Ability to code in C#]) is probably much more important than [Communication] competency.
With this method, a [weight] or percentage is assigned to each competency, ensuring that the weights add up to 100% (or 1.0). Weighting example:
Competency 1 (C# Coding): 60% (Weight: 0.6)
Competency 2 (Teamwork): 30% (Weight: 0.3)
Competency 3 (Communication): 10% (Weight: 0.1)
Calculating the Weighted Score
The calculation is done in two steps. First, each competency score is multiplied by its weight to get the [Adjusted Score].
Then, all adjusted scores are added to get the total. Calculation example (using the scores from Method 1):
Competency 1: Score (3) x Weight (0.6) = Adjusted Score 1.8
Competency 2: Score (4) x Weight (0.3) = Adjusted Score 1.2
Competency 3: Score (5) x Weight (0.1) = Adjusted Score 0.5
Final calculation: 1.8 + 1.2 + 0.5 = Final score: 3.5 out of 5.
As the example shows, the final weighted score (3.5) is lower than the simple score (4.0).
scoring methods simple vs weighted