Procedures for Handling False and Incomplete STARs

Select the language:

ℹ️
Please log in to have your progress recorded. Without logging in, you can view the video, but your progress in the course will not be tracked.

Procedures for Handling False and Incomplete STARs


Identify and manage deficient responses in interviews with effective strategies learned in our pragmatic course designed for interviewers.

Identifying Poor Responses

Not every answer a candidate gives during a behavioral interview will be a [complete STAR].

It is the interviewer’s responsibility to identify poor answers and know how to handle them.

There are mainly two types of problematic answers: the [False STAR] and the [Incomplete STAR].

A False STAR occurs when the candidate does not provide a concrete example of a past event.

Instead of telling a story, the candidate speaks in theoretical terms or generalities.

For example, if asked about leadership, they might answer: [Leadership is very important to me, and I believe a good leader should motivate their team], without citing any real situation in which they did so.

An Incomplete STAR, which is more common, occurs when the candidate tells a story but leaves out one of the model’s four critical components: the Situation, Task, Action, or Result.

Strategy 1: How to Handle a [False STAR] (Theoretical Answers)

When a candidate responds with theory instead of an example, the interviewer’s goal is to gently redirect them toward a specific experience. Do not accept the theoretical answer.

Instead, use probing questions designed to bring past events to mind. Some effective questions include:

  • [I understand your theoretical point, but can you recall a specific time when something like that happened to you?].
  • [Can you share a recent example from your work where you applied that?].
  • [Think back to one of your previous jobs: when did you face that kind of situation?].

Strategy 2: How to Handle an [Incomplete STAR] (Missing Pieces)

When a component of the STAR model is missing from the candidate’s account, follow-up questions should be precise and focus directly on the missing element.

If the Situation (S) or Task (T) is missing: The candidate jumps straight to the action without explaining the context or their role.

Ask: [What exactly was happening at that moment?].

Ask: [What task were you assigned?] or [What exactly were you expected to do?].

If the Action (A) is missing: This is the most critical error. It occurs when the candidate describes the situation and the result, but not what they did, or when they keep speaking in the plural ([we decided], [the team resolved it]). The key is to refocus them on [I].

Ask: [What exactly did you do?].

Ask: [How did you personally act in that situation?].

If the Result (R) is missing: The candidate explains what they did but not how things turned out.

Ask: [And how did it all end?].

Ask: [What consequences did your actions have?].

Best Practices for Getting a Complete STAR

The main goal is to get the best and clearest example possible. To do so, the interviewer should:

Allow Time: Never rush the candidate if they are thinking. Give them time to recall a good example.

Be empathetic with phrases such as: [Take your time] or [Don’t worry, it doesn’t have to be a perfect situation]. If they still cannot recall anything, it is better to move on to the next question.


handling false and incomplete stars

Unlock the full course and get certified!

You are viewing free content. Unlock the full course to get your certificate, exams, and downloadable material.

*When you purchase the course, we gift you two courses of your choice*

*See the best deal on the web*

Is there any error or improvement?

Where is the error?

What is the error?